The below list of players have been seen by Gotham Hoops and are part of the 2011 class (no specific order):
| Player | Position | Height | School | Committed |
| Corey Edwards | PG | 5’10″ | Christ the King (Queens) | |
| Achraf Yacoubou | G/F | 6’4″ | LuHi (Long Island) | Villanova |
| Jabarie Hinds | G | 6’1″ | Mt. Vernon (Westchester) | |
| Davontay Grace | PG | 6’2″ | Thomas Jefferson (Brooklyn) | St. John’s |
| Mike Taylor | SG | 6’3″ | Boys & Girls (Brooklyn) | |
| Tavon Sledge | PG | 5’9″ | Hills West (Long Island) | |
| Maurice Harkless | F | 6’7″ | Forest Hills (Queens) | UCONN |
| Kamari Murphy | F | 6’8″ | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | |
| Jermaine Sanders | G/F | 6’3″ | Rice (Manhattan) | |
| Jordan Allen | G/F | 6’3″ | Bayshore (Long Island) | |
| Shaquille Stokes | PG | 5’10″ | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | |
| Chris Gayot | PG | 6’1″ | Benjamin Cardozo (Queens) | |
| David Burgos | PG | 6’0″ | Wadliegh (Manhattan) | |
| Marquise Barnett | F | 6’6″ | Benjamin Cardozo (Queens) | |
| Sheldon Hagigal | G | 5’11″ | Westbury (Long Island) | |
| Peter Aguilar | G | 6’3″ | Mt. Saint Michael | |
| Darrel Lucky | PG | 5’11″ | Paul Robeson (Brooklyn) | |
| Shamel Williams | G/F | 6’4″ | Thomas Jefferson (Brooklyn) | |
| Emmanuel Andujar | G | 6’4″ | Rice (Manhattan) | |
| Davone Henry | G | 6’3″ | Bread & Roses (Westchester) | |
| Tyler Harris | F | 6’7″ | Hills West (Long Island) | |
| Terrel Hunt | G/F | 6’4″ | Christ the King (Queens) | |
| Evan Conti | G | 6’3″ | Holy Cross (Queens) | |
| Conroy Baltimore | F | 6’5″ | Stepinac (Westchester) | |
| Edson Avila | F/C | 6’8″ | Thomas Jefferson (Brooklyn) | |
| Dantre Langhorne | G | 6’3″ | Greenport (Long Island) | |
| T.J. Curry | PG | 6’0″ | Christ the King (Queens) | |
| Marcus Hopper | F | 6’8″ | Holy Cross (Queens) | |
| Darien Croft | PG | 5’11″ | Amityville (Long Island) | |
| Kareem Canty | G | 6’1″ | Bishop Loughlin (Bronx) | |
| Tyler Seidman | G | 6’0″ | Holy Trinity (Long Island) | |
| Rob Goldstein | PG | 5’11″ | Seaford (Long Island) | |
| Antoine Slaughter | PG | 5’8″ | Boys & Girls (Brooklyn) | |
| Devin Brooks | G | 6’1″ | St. Raymond (Bronx) | |
| Darien Davis | PG | 5’11″ | Longwood (Long Island) | |
| Manny Thomas | F | 6’4″ | Xaverian (Brooklyn) | |
| David Rucker | G | 6’2″ | Blessed Sacrament (Westchester) | |
| Mike Florin | PG | 5’10″ | LuHi (Long Island) | |
| Jordan Dickerson | C | 6’11″ | Abraham Lincoln (Brooklyn) | |
